When Cassie, 26, traded in her aging Jeep Wrangler for a Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD, she thought she was making a smart move.
Her Jeep was racking up miles and starting to need repairs, and because she wasn’t paying rent or a mortgage with her boyfriend, she felt she had room in her budget for a bigger payment. She financed roughly $60,000 for the truck, including negative equity rolled over from her Jeep.
Must Read
A year later, however, her situation changed. A job transfer turned her commute into a 100-mile daily drive, sending her diesel costs higher. A potential move means she’ll soon need to contribute toward housing expenses too.
Now she’s paying about $900 a month for a truck she rarely drives, relying instead on another vehicle she owns outright because it’s cheaper to operate.
The bigger problem: She still owes about $53,000 on the loan, but the truck is worth about $39,000.
She’s now weighing whether to sell the truck privately and take out a loan to cover the difference, or trade it in for something cheaper and roll the remaining debt into another vehicle.
Cassie’s situation is becoming increasingly common.
According to data from Edmunds, more than three in 10 Americans trading in a vehicle owe more than it’s worth. Buyers carrying negative equity financed an average of nearly $56,000 in the first quarter of 2026, while their average monthly payment reached a record $932.
Regaining control of the situation
For Cassie, the hardest part isn’t just the $900 monthly payment. It’s that the reason the payment once seemed manageable has disappeared.
When she bought the truck, she wasn’t facing a housing payment. She expected to have extra room in her budget and planned to put more money toward the loan after a job change. Then her commute changed, fuel costs climbed, and her living situation started to shift.
That’s how many people end up feeling stuck with a vehicle loan — the math works when they sign the paperwork, but life doesn’t always stick to the plan.
The fact that Cassie owes about $53,000 on a truck worth around $39,000 adds another challenge. She can’t simply sell the Silverado and walk away.
The roughly $14,000 gap between what she owes and what the truck is worth would still need to be covered. She could pay the difference herself, borrow money to cover it, or roll that remaining balance into another auto loan.
Before deciding what to do next, Cassie may want to get a better sense of the truck’s real market value. A few trade-in offers, online estimates, and private-sale comparisons could show whether the gap is as wide as she thinks — and help her weigh her options.
Rolling the debt into another vehicle might seem like the easiest escape route, but it can create a new problem. Instead of starting fresh with a cheaper vehicle, she could end up financing a car she can’t comfortably afford while still carrying debt from the truck.
Edmunds found that borrowers who trade in vehicles with negative equity often end up financing more and taking on higher monthly payments than buyers who start with positive equity.
Selling the truck privately may be one option worth exploring. A private buyer may pay more than a dealership would offer on a trade-in, which could shrink the amount Cassie needs to cover. But she would still need a plan for the remaining balance.
Refinancing could lower Cassie’s monthly payment, but it may not solve the bigger problem. Stretching out the loan could mean paying more interest, and finding a lender willing to refinance a vehicle that’s worth less than the remaining balance may be difficult.
The other option is keeping the truck and attacking the loan balance.
Because Cassie already has another vehicle she can drive, she has more flexibility than someone who needs the truck for work or daily transportation. If she can handle the payment for now and put extra money toward the loan when possible, she may eventually close the gap between what she owes and what the truck is worth.
There’s no easy way out of a loan like this, and every option comes with a downside. For Cassie, the goal isn’t finding a perfect solution — it’s finding the one that gives her the most financial breathing room as her life changes.
The challenge with a car loan is that you’re committing to a payment for years — even though your life and your budget can change a lot during that time.
Experts recommend looking at the total cost of ownership, including fuel, insurance, maintenance, registration, and depreciation. A vehicle that fits comfortably into today’s budget may become much harder to afford if your circumstances change.
Edmunds also suggests avoiding rolling negative equity into another loan whenever possible and shopping carefully for financing before visiting a dealership.
Vehicle payments have climbed steadily in recent years. Experian reports the average monthly payment on a new vehicle reached $767 by the end of 2025, while the average financed amount climbed to more than $43,500.
For Cassie, the truck that once felt like a reward has become a source of daily stress.
Getting out from under it may take time — and likely some difficult financial decisions — but avoiding another cycle of negative equity could ultimately put her in a much stronger position as she works toward her next goal: helping pay for a home.
What To Read Next
Join 250,000+ readers and get Moneywise’s best stories and exclusive interviews first — clear insights curated and delivered weekly. Subscribe now.
