• Home
  • Politics
  • Health
  • World
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Tech
  • More
    • Sports
    • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
What's Hot

DeSantis Signs Bill Making Gold And Silver Legal Tender

May 28, 2025

John Deere Announces $20 Billion Plan To Build Up American Manufacturing

May 28, 2025

EV Startup Promised To Cut China Ties — Then Reportedly Shared US Data Anyway

May 27, 2025
Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
Thursday, May 29
Patriot Now NewsPatriot Now News
  • Home
  • Politics

    Security video shows brazen sexual assault of California woman by homeless man

    October 24, 2023

    Woman makes disturbing discovery after her boyfriend chases away home intruder who stabbed him

    October 24, 2023

    Poll finds Americans overwhelmingly support Israel’s war on Hamas, but younger Americans defend Hamas

    October 24, 2023

    Off-duty pilot charged with 83 counts of attempted murder after allegedly trying to shut off engines midflight on Alaska Airlines

    October 23, 2023

    Leaked audio of Shelia Jackson Lee abusively cursing staffer

    October 22, 2023
  • Health

    Disparities In Cataract Care Are A Sorry Sight

    October 16, 2023

    Vaccine Stocks—Including Pfizer, Moderna, BioNTech And Novavax—Slide Amid Plummeting Demand

    October 16, 2023

    Long-term steroid use should be a last resort

    October 16, 2023

    Rite Aid Files For Bankruptcy With More ‘Underperforming Stores’ To Close

    October 16, 2023

    Who’s Still Dying From Complications Related To Covid-19?

    October 16, 2023
  • World

    New York Democrat Dan Goldman Accuses ‘Conservatives in the South’ of Holding Rallies with ‘Swastikas’

    October 13, 2023

    IDF Ret. Major General Describes Rushing to Save Son, Granddaughter During Hamas Invasion

    October 13, 2023

    Black Lives Matter Group Deletes Tweet Showing Support for Hamas 

    October 13, 2023

    AOC Denounces NYC Rally Cheering Hamas Terrorism: ‘Unacceptable’

    October 13, 2023

    L.A. Prosecutors Call Out Soros-Backed Gascón for Silence on Israel

    October 13, 2023
  • Business

    DeSantis Signs Bill Making Gold And Silver Legal Tender

    May 28, 2025

    John Deere Announces $20 Billion Plan To Build Up American Manufacturing

    May 28, 2025

    EV Startup Promised To Cut China Ties — Then Reportedly Shared US Data Anyway

    May 27, 2025

    Corporate America Retreats From Gay Pride Events Across US Amid Trump DEI Crackdown

    May 24, 2025

    New AI Model Would Rather Ruin Your Life Than Be Turned Off, Researchers Say

    May 23, 2025
  • Finance

    Ending China’s De Minimis Exception Brings 3 Benefits for Americans

    April 17, 2025

    The Trump Tariff Shock Should Push Indonesia to Reform Its Economy

    April 17, 2025

    Tariff Talks an Opportunity to Reinvigorate the Japan-US Alliance

    April 17, 2025

    How China’s Companies Are Responding to the US Trade War

    April 16, 2025

    The US Flip-flop Over H20 Chip Restrictions 

    April 16, 2025
  • Tech

    Cruz Confronts Zuckerberg on Pointless Warning for Child Porn Searches

    February 2, 2024

    FTX Abandons Plans to Relaunch Crypto Exchange, Commits to Full Repayment of Customers and Creditors

    February 2, 2024

    Elon Musk Proposes Tesla Reincorporates in Texas After Delaware Judge Voids Pay Package

    February 2, 2024

    Tesla’s Elon Musk Tops Disney’s Bob Iger as Most Overrated Chief Executive

    February 2, 2024

    Mark Zuckerberg’s Wealth Grew $84 Billion in 2023 as Pedophiles Target Children on Facebook, Instagram

    February 2, 2024
  • More
    • Sports
    • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
Patriot Now NewsPatriot Now News
Home»Finance»Why Do China Bulls Keep Getting It Wrong?
Finance

Why Do China Bulls Keep Getting It Wrong?

October 11, 2024No Comments7 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Why Do China Bulls Keep Getting It Wrong?
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

The monetary stimulus announced by the People’s Bank of China (PBOC) at the end of September seems to have achieved little. After two weeks of frenzied buying followed by a day of massive selloffs, the market rallies in Hong Kong and mainland China appear to be over. It is unlikely that the short-lived rallies catalyzed actual investments, improved the lives of Chinese citizens (most of whom do not own shares), or enhanced prospects of the real economy.

A much-anticipated fiscal stimulus that might boost domestic consumption has not yet materialized. Earlier this week, a press conference by the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) did worse than fall short of market expectations; the dearth of substantive measures that could have enhanced domestic consumption and private investment caused the Hang Seng index to fall by nearly 10 percent on the same day, wiping out most of the index’s gains for the year.

Perhaps the only thing more dramatic than the turbulence of Hong Kong and Chinese stock markets in recent weeks has been the mental gymnastics of China bulls and optimists as they try to explain the actions of a government prone to giving mixed signals, sudden reversals, and policy U-turns.

Recall for instance how the Chinese state abruptly swung from a strict zero-COVID policy to a de facto COVID-for-everyone policy at the end of 2022 – leading to the very dystopia that Chinese state media had, for the previous two years, mocked Western countries for. A few months later, the Chinese authorities brazenly declared that China’s COVID-19 policy had been “completely correct” even as they scrubbed references to the tight restrictions that had traumatized the economy for much of the pandemic. 

When one tries to attribute intentionality and rationality to such dramatic policy U-turns, it is hardly surprising that the resulting “explanations” are a hodge-podge of implausible claims, non sequiturs, wishful thinking, and delusional optimism. 

See also  Asia private equity 2022 deals fell 44%; uncertainty ahead

Before the monetary stimulus announced by PBOC three weeks ago, China bulls were saying that a stimulus was not only unnecessary, but also unhealthy for China’s development. They claimed that a sizable stimulus would undo the progress China has made in moving away from speculative investments mostly in real estate to a “high-quality” development model driven by advanced manufacturing and cutting-edge technologies. Deleveraging was framed as a necessary process, even a desirable one, as the economy unwound years of debt-fueled investments in real estate.

They also pointed to the United States as an example of how fiscal and monetary stimuli led to high indebtedness, an economy built on financial speculation and asset bubbles, over-consumption, and runaway inflation. By contrast, China was a model of financial and fiscal rectitude; it will not run the risk of reflating the bubbles that the authorities had successfully deflated in the last few years.

Fair enough, one might think. But when the PBOC did a volte face and unleashed China’s version of a monetary stimulus that included unprecedented measures to boost domestic equities, China bulls immediately applauded the moves even though intellectual integrity required the opposite. Their “explanation” now was that after stomping on real estate developers such as Evergrande and stabilizing the property market, the time was ripe for the authorities to ease credit conditions and pump prime the economy – starting with the stock market.

The stock market rally that followed the PBOC’s announcements was thus hailed as a sign of the Chinese economy roaring back to life, and as evidence that the naysayers who predicted that China would fail to meet its 5 percent growth target for the year were wrong. Any suggestion that the stock market rally would be short-lived was shot down. Similarly, concerns that the stock market rally might become a bubble were rubbished; Chinese equities, the bulls insisted, were still undervalued. 

For China bulls, the stimulus announced by the PBOC marked the culmination of a highly coordinated series of policy measures taken to prevent “the disorderly expansion of capital” (the Communist Party’s favored justification for any crackdown on private enterprises), restructure the economy, and upgrade its technological and productive capabilities. The regulatory crackdowns of the last three years – on property developers, internet platform companies, private education, and others – were now framed as part of a well-conceived plan aimed at draining the economy of its excesses, even if that led to sluggish growth and falling prices.

See also  Stocks making biggest moves premarket: Dick's, Fabrinet, Macy's

In the (new) narrative of China bulls, the problems the Chinese economy has been struggling with the last two years – deflation, decline in asset prices, deleveraging, falling corporate profits – were not sacrifices in vain. Rather, they were the planned and intended consequences of China’s upgrading efforts.

As if all that was not delusional enough, these bulls confidently predicted that China would soon launch a big fiscal bazooka that would extend the stock market rally and catalyze a wider economic recovery – enabling China to hit the target of 5 percent GDP growth. But that fiscal stimulus did not come. Hong Kong’s stock market fell by over 9 percent on Tuesday because market expectations ran far ahead of what the the NDRC was prepared to do to spur growth. 

At the heart of the eternal, but mostly unjustified, optimism of China bulls is their unshakeable belief that the Chinese state is exceptional. For the bulls, China’s leaders are unusually intelligent, far-sighted, and meritocratic; they formulate policies rationally based on science and evidence. It is a government for the people rather than one captured by vested interests.

Viewing the Chinese government through this prism of exceptionalism makes it hard for China bulls to imagine that the authorities might be unpredictable, capricious, and prone to sudden U-turns. Hence, when the policy reversals and U-turns occur, China bulls must construct elaborate and often implausible theories to “explain” them. Not doing so would cause too much cognitive dissonance.

The reality of course is that the Chinese state is not all that exceptional. Like the governments of most countries, it is often myopic and torn between short- and long-term goals; ideology and loyalty regularly come into conflict with rational, meritocratic decision-making; and there is a large gap between (legitimate) policy goals and the Chinese state’s capacity to achieve those goals. In short, the reason the China bulls often get it wrong is that the authorities they feel compelled to defend and justify are themselves often wrong.

See also  Global economies are out of sync; 2024 will be a ‘year of contraction’

There is also a deeper pathology behind an instinctive defense of whatever the Chinese authorities do. About a century ago, the great Chinese novelist Lu Xun explained China’s inability to modernize in terms of self-delusion, embodied by the title character in his short story “The True Story of Ah Q.” For Lu Xun, China’s malaise was not just the result of Western aggression or the West’s superior technologies. Rather, the roots of China’s malaise were found in a flawed “national character.” 

Lu Xun’s writing gave birth to the concept of the “Ah Q mentality”: essentially an exaggerated form of denial, delusional optimism, and self-rationalization. In the face of defeat, rather than acknowledge his own shortcomings, Ah Q deceives and persuades himself that he is (morally) superior to his adversaries. No defeat or humiliation is large enough to undermine his unfounded and deluded sense of self-superiority. 

Just as the Ah Q mentality held back China’s modernization a century ago, similar thought patterns are holding back the necessary reforms that would propel China into the league of developed countries. By denying the fact that China faces very real economic problems and by deluding themselves of China’s superiority, China bulls do far more harm than good for the country’s development. 

bulls China wrong
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

Related Posts

EV Startup Promised To Cut China Ties — Then Reportedly Shared US Data Anyway

May 27, 2025

OpenAI CEO Warns: ‘Not A Huge Amount Of Time’ Until China Overpowers American AI

May 9, 2025

Trump’s Tariffs Trigger Turmoil In China As Country’s Economic Tailspin Intensifies Per New Data

May 6, 2025

American Manufacturers Overwhelmed With Orders After Trump’s Tariff Crackdown On China

May 5, 2025
Add A Comment

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Top Posts

Biden Administration in ‘Intelligence Denial’ on Iran

October 13, 2023

Market Rally Breaks Key Levels; Two Cathie Wood Stocks Report Late With Apple, Amazon On Tap

August 3, 2023

US consumer sentiment sours; dollar aiding inflation fight

October 14, 2023

I saw People Being ‘Sexually Harassed’ While on Set as a Child

May 22, 2023
Don't Miss

DeSantis Signs Bill Making Gold And Silver Legal Tender

Business May 28, 2025

Republican Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signed a bill Tuesday recognizing gold and silver coins as…

John Deere Announces $20 Billion Plan To Build Up American Manufacturing

May 28, 2025

EV Startup Promised To Cut China Ties — Then Reportedly Shared US Data Anyway

May 27, 2025

101 Inspirational August Quotes for a Happy and Positive End to the Summer

May 27, 2025
About
About

This is your World, Tech, Health, Entertainment and Sports website. We provide the latest breaking news straight from the News industry.

We're social. Connect with us:

Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest
Categories
  • Business (4,134)
  • Entertainment (4,220)
  • Finance (3,202)
  • Health (1,938)
  • Lifestyle (1,645)
  • Politics (3,084)
  • Sports (4,036)
  • Tech (2,006)
  • Uncategorized (4)
  • World (3,944)
Our Picks

Donald Trump Participates in LIV Golf’s Pro-Am at Trump National DC

May 26, 2023

US Rejects Report China To Build Cuba Spy Base

June 8, 2023

Bryan Kohberger Had Flashlight & 4 Pairs Of Gloves On Him During Arrest, Unsealed Warrant Reveals

February 28, 2023
Popular Posts

DeSantis Signs Bill Making Gold And Silver Legal Tender

May 28, 2025

John Deere Announces $20 Billion Plan To Build Up American Manufacturing

May 28, 2025

EV Startup Promised To Cut China Ties — Then Reportedly Shared US Data Anyway

May 27, 2025
© 2025 Patriotnownews.com - All rights reserved.
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.